Black Tie Shoes: What to Wear With a Tuxedo
With a tuxedo, wear black oxfords: polished or patent black leather, closed lacing, a plain or cap toe, a thin sole, and no brogue holes. Add black socks that reach the calf and trousers with little or no break. That is black tie. Everything else in the room can be loud; the shoe is not.
Here is the rule in full, the two traditional alternatives, and the mistakes we see at every wedding and gala.
Why the oxford
An oxford has closed lacing: the two sides that carry the eyelets are stitched under the front of the shoe, so they sit flat and close together. It is the cleanest lace-up there is, which is why it belongs with the cleanest outfit a man owns. A derby, with its open lacing, is a fine shoe for a suit and the wrong one for a dinner jacket.
Our Dario Lombardi Leather Oxford is cut for exactly this: black leather that takes a high shine, closed lacing, a cap toe and a slim sole.
The shoe rule, line by line
- Colour: black. Not dark brown, not oxblood, not navy.
- Finish: patent leather or black calf polished to a mirror at the toe. Matte or suede reads as daywear.
- Toe: plain or a simple cap toe. No wingtip, no medallion, no brogue holes.
- Lacing: closed (oxford). Flat black laces, waxed if you have them.
- Sole: thin and close-cut, so the shoe looks slim under the trouser.
The two traditional alternatives
Opera pumps. A low patent slipper with a grosgrain bow. The most formal option of all, correct for white tie and still correct for black tie, if you can carry it.
Velvet slippers. For a black-tie dinner at home or a smoking-jacket evening. Not for a gala, not for a wedding.
Loafers, boots and sneakers do not belong with a tuxedo, however the photographs on social media dress them up.
Socks: black, fine, over the calf
Black silk or fine merino socks that reach the calf, so no skin shows when you sit and cross your legs. Patterned socks are for the after-party, not for the table.
The trouser break
Tuxedo trousers have a satin stripe down the side and no turn-ups. Hem them so they just touch the top of the shoe, a slight break at most. A trouser that puddles on the shoe hides the one thing you polished.
The red under the sole
Some of our dress shoes carry a thin line of red under the sole. Standing up, the shoe reads black: the heel block and the sole edge are black, and the red only shows when you walk or cross a leg. That is the point of it. It is for the dance floor and nowhere else.
Before the evening
- Polish the toe and heel the night before, not in the car.
- Wear the shoes for an hour at home first if they are new; a dinner is a long time to stand.
- Carry nothing in the trouser pockets. The line of the trouser shows the shoe.
See every dress shoe in the collection, with the 30-day money-back guarantee on each pair.
Questions we get
Can you wear regular black dress shoes with a tuxedo?
Yes, if they are black oxfords with closed lacing, no brogueing, and a high polish. A matte derby or a brogue is the wrong shoe.
Do black tie shoes have to be patent leather?
No. Patent is traditional; well-polished black calf is equally correct and easier to live with.
Can you wear loafers with a tuxedo?
Velvet slippers at home, yes. Leather loafers to a black-tie event, no.
What colour socks go with a tuxedo?
Black, in silk or fine wool, long enough to cover the calf.